Skip to main content

As I Lay Dying From an Outsider's Point of View

Almost all of the main characters in As I Lay Dying are incredibly strange from an outside perspective. Growing up physically and metaphorically separated from a lot of people, the Bundren family's idiosyncrasies are exaggerated. Anse's preoccupation with his teeth, laziness, and self-pity are strengthened by the other members of his family and neighbors doing all of the work around the farm. Vardaman's preoccupation with his mother as a fish is ignored by almost everyone, save for Darl, who encourages it and adds that Jewel's mother is a horse. Cash is perhaps the most normal of the family, and yet he throws himself into building the coffin, obsessing over making it perfect.

To almost every outside perspective, the Bundrens appear cartoonish, disrespectful, strange, and often unsettling. The first point of view character who didn't know the Bundrens beforehand, Armstid, says in his chapter that the Bundrens "wouldn't even stay, and that boy chasing them buzzards all day in the hot sun until he was nigh as crazy as the rest of them." (page 191). From Vardaman's point of view, him chasing away the buzzards is a perfectly logical thing to do, but to an outside perspective, he looks incredibly strange. Anse refuses Armstid's offer of food/help, which would make him seem heroic except for the fact that he has no reason to refuse it. 

The next outsider that encountered the Bundrens was Samson, who says that "a woman that's been dead in a box for four days, the best way to respect her is to get her into the ground quick as you can. But they [the Bundrens] wouldn't do it." (page 116). Samson's wife is visibly disturbed by the Bundrens, and especially their treatment of Addie. Their framing of the Bundrens' journey is less like a road of trials and more like them disrespecting Addie's body and memory. Samson sees their actions as rude, stubborn, and irreverent. This also emphasizes how the Bundrens' (especially Anse's) ideas of respect are far removed from the accepted ideas of the people around them. 

In Moseley's chapter, he introduces the Bundrens as "It had been dead eight days, albert said. They came from some place out in Yoknapatawpha county, trying to get to Jefferson with it [Addie]." (page 203). Moseley is one of the few town characters that get a chapter, and shows a disgust for the Bundrens beyond what he would normally feel for people from the country. As more time passes from Addie's death, and she starts to rot, all of the characters (including the Bundrens to some extent) begin to think of her less as a person and more as an object, which is at odds to their heroic demeanor. Moseley then describes the coffin, which Cash tirelessly worked on for days as "that home-made box" (page 203), with the connotation that it is as shabby and crude. Moseley's chapter solidifies the doubt that the Bundrens do not appear as heroes.

Despite Anse framing the journey as a favor he is doing for Addie, everyone outside of the family views it as him disrespecting the dead and, as the journey stretches on and they get further from the people who know them, as disgusting. Even the Bundrens begin to think of the journey as less of a quest and more of a chore, with many of the characters abandoning the pretense of respecting Addie's last wishes. 

Comments

  1. I really like your analysis of the outsiders' view of the Bundrens. I think that Faulker wrote in the outsiders to vindicate the reader's view of the Bundrens. As the book goes on, the reader might start sympathizing with the family and start to disagree with the Outsiders, namely MacGowan.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post, I think viewing the Bundrens' journey from the perspective of the outsiders adds another angle to the reader's interpretation of the book as a Hero's Journey. Most outsiders seem to think Anse is disrespecting his wife rather than honoring her by waiting to bury her in Jefferson, and since he had ulterior motives in making the journey, they're kind of right. To be honest, he probably wouldn't have gone at all if there weren't other things he wanted to accomplish in town. Nobody is fully focused on respecting Addie and getting her to Jefferson as soon as possible, and this is reflected in the way their actions look to outsiders.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Helena, Michael, and the Divorce

Black Swan Green ends with the divorce of Jason's parents and his impending move to Cheltenham. Although Jason remains oblivious to the problems in their marriage for a long time, the cracks in their relationship begin to show as early as the first chapter. Despite their argument about both redoing the kitchen and getting a rockery in the backyard (both things that Helena wants, but Michael is against), both of those things end up happening. Even after Helena and Michael clash over her job offer, Helena still 'wins' in the end and ends up working in Cheltenham. These arguments show the beginning of the separation between Helena and Michael, as well as Helena's growing independence, which is what allows her to get the divorce in the first place.  The first indication that all is not as it seems between Helena and Michael is during the first chapter, where Jason is so focused on explaining why he went into his father's office to notice the tension between his parents....

Achilles and the Hero's Journey

Joseph Campbell, as a comparative mythology scholar, is best known for his work codifying the Hero's Journey story structure. He proposed the idea of a 'monomyth', or a common template that follows a hero going on an adventure and returning, changed that is present in all stories.  Campbell split the monomyth template into 17 steps. Not all of the steps are always present, and the steps may not always be in the same order, but they are typically divided into three larger sections, or acts: the Departure (or Separation), the Initiation and the Return (1). These steps symbolize the hero's descent into the unknown adventure as well as their eventual return to the world they know. One of the epics that greatly influenced the idea of the monomyth was the Iliad. The Iliad is a piece of ancient Greek epic poetry. The journey of Achilles, as told in the Iliad, follows the Hero's Journey steps set out by Campbell.  Both the Iliad and the Odyssey most likely originated ...

Esther Greenwood and the Miraculous Recovery

Even before Esther is officially deemed fit to be released from the asylum, she knows that the bell jar that had been suffocating her before had lifted. Although she doesn't know for certain whether it will ever return, she feels newly empowered to continue with life. The reason for this is that she no longer has the looming pressure of people expecting her to be great in the future. These expectations that people had before of Esther were a major part of why she attempted to commit suicide. Esther was a high-achieving, straight-A student who was able to go to college through the many scholarships that she earned. She is able to skip being graded on a required class because of everyone's belief that she would have aced the course anyway. As a result of her previous achievements, she begins feeling pressure to be great even after graduating college, which she's not sure how to do in the absence of grades and papers. During her New York internship, when Esther realizes for th...